Do I Need Title Insurance When Paying Cash For a Home?

No, but it is a wise idea.  When you pay cash for a home, you may think it’s permanently yours and no one can take it. However, if there’s a problem with the title it can threaten your ownership rights. That’s why banks normally require a lender’s policy when you take out a mortgage to pay. When it’s just you and you’re using cash, you’re the one taking on the liability and that is why having an owner’s policy is a smart idea.  But what is the likelihood something could happen?  Here’s some examples.

If a past owner used a fictitious name or forged a notarization on a document during a previous closing, it can break the chain of title and affect all of the transactions that happen afterward.  Your title company will do their best to detect forgeries while researching records and the property’s history, but there is also room for error, especially when someone lied about who they were or a name was signed incorrectly in the early or mid 1900’s.  There is a lot of room for error.  You also have liens.

If a person claims and can prove that a previous owner owed them money or a debt, you may end up losing your home, or the land it is on.  This doesn’t have to be recent, it could be 5 years ago or even dating back decades.  Was the home built or owned by someone pre-stock market crash in the 20’s?  What about the .com bubble burst?  Either of these could have caused the previous owner to have a debt that could come back to haunt you.  That is something your title company may not be able to find. A third example which should hit close to home for many of us are clerical errors.

Have you ever called to have something refilled at a pharmacy and the person was swamped and mistyped your name and couldn’t find you?  Maybe you needed a record looked up and the person couldn’t hear exactly what you said and asked you to repeat yourself two or three times.  It could even be that someone misspelled your last name, and it now becomes a hassle for you to get it changed even though it was that company’s employee that made the mistake?  The same thing that happens then could cost you your home.

You are probably not the first person to own the property, and with it transferring ownership multiple times and numerous employees re-entering transactional data, there’s a good chance there could be clerical errors.  These errors whether they’re filing or getting the name wrong because the person was working late one night are costly.  And because you paid cash, they are your financial burden to fix.

Even if you paid cash for your home, it can be taken away like in the examples above.  Defending it can be incredibly costly with legal fees and that is why it is recommended you buy a title insurance policy, especially in cash deals.